Tiered Medical Care: Primary Care Accounts for 90%, Yet Medical Centers Still Treat Minor Illnesses

In 2024, primary care outpatient visits reached 92.01% of the total, while hospital shares fell to 35.91%. However, primary care rates at medical centers are rising; the NHIA is deploying strategic alliances and referral point adjustments to address this.

In 2024, the proportion of outpatient visits in Western medicine primary care was 92.01%, accounting for 64.09% of total claims; hospital departments fell to 35.91%.1

Another set of figures from the same year shows an opposite trend: the primary care rate for hospitals at the regional hospital level or above was 18.37%, higher than the 17.21% recorded in 2022; medical centers also rose from 14.40% to 15.56%.1

Primary care is getting stronger, yet hospitals are still treating minor illnesses. Both of these facts hold true simultaneously.

Two Curves

First, look at primary care. The proportion of outpatient visits in Western medicine primary care was 89.49% in 2022, 91.79% in 2023, and 92.01% in 2024; the share of total claims rose from 61.50% to 63.99%, and then to 64.09%.1

Meanwhile, the share of claims for hospital departments fell from 38.50% to 36.01%, and then to 35.91%.1

Proportion of Outpatient Visits and Share of Claims in Western Medicine (2024) (%)
Primary Care
Number of Visits 92.01
Hospitals
Number of Visits 62.20
Primary Care
Share of Claims 64.09
Hospitals
Share of Claims 35.91

Source: NHIA "2024 National Health Insurance Supervisory Indicator Monitoring Report," Indicator 1.5

The denominator for the proportion of outpatient visits is the total number of Western medicine outpatient visits. If the same person visits both a clinic and a hospital, they are counted in both places; therefore, the sum of these two figures exceeds 100%. The share of claims does not have this issue, as it sums to 100%.1

But Hospitals Are Still Treating Minor Illnesses

Primary care refers to illnesses suitable for management at primary care clinics or regional hospitals, such as influenza, intestinal infections, acute bronchitis, skin and subcutaneous tissue infections, chondrocalcinosis, joint disorders, urinary tract infections, etc.1

This classification stems from research by Professor Wu Hsiao-chi of Yang-Ming University in 2003, which was later revised with the assistance of family medicine and primary care specialists; it is not an internationally standardized definition.1

The primary care rate for hospitals at the regional level or above has shown a slight upward trend over three years: 17.21%, 18.01%, and 18.37%. Looking at the breakdown for 2024, medical centers stood at 15.56%, regional hospitals at 20.18%, and district hospitals at 30.51%, with the overall hospital average at 21.57%.1

Primary Care Rate for Hospitals at Regional Level or Above (%)
Primary Care Rate for Hospitals at Regional Level or Above (%)18.3715.132023202417.21Medical Center: 14.40
Primary Care Rate for Hospitals at Regional Level or Above (%)
202217.21Medical Center: 14.40
202318.0115.13
202418.3715.56

Source: NHIA "2024 National Health Insurance Supervisory Indicator Monitoring Report," Indicator 1.4

The lower the hospital tier, the higher the primary care rate, which aligns with the system's design: district hospitals are intended to handle more general illnesses. The real concern is medical centers—NHIA committee members have long focused on the phenomenon of "bloated outpatient departments" or medical centers "treating minor illnesses."1

Why Is This Happening?

The National Health Insurance Administration (NHIA) attributes the rise since 2020 to the pandemic, suggesting that patients may have visited hospitals because they could not determine for themselves whether they were infected, thereby increasing the primary care rate at hospitals of regional level or above.1

Another clue is the reduction in outpatient volume. Based on the share of claims within the scope of "outpatient volume reduction" implemented in 2017, the first quarter of 2025 was 57.4%, a decrease of 0.6 percentage points from 58% in the same period last year; the second quarter was 57.8%, also a decrease of 0.3 percentage points from 58.1% in the same period last year.1

Under this metric, the share of claims only decreased by 0.3 to 0.6 percentage points within a year.

Policy Tools: Alliances, Referral Points, and Co-management

The NHIA's improvement strategies include the "Everyone's Doctor" program, strategic alliances, referral points, and co-management pilots. Below, we discuss the latter three.1

First is vertical integration. As of the end of June 2025, 81 strategic alliances have been formed across Taiwan, involving 6,844 contracted medical institutions. This includes 28 medical centers, 78 regional hospitals, 282 district hospitals, 6,305 primary care clinics, 141 home care agencies, 6 psychiatric rehabilitation institutions, and 4 respiratory care centers.1

Second is referral incentives. Starting September 1, 2025, the payment points for downward referrals (referring a patient to a lower tier) and receiving downward referrals will be increased. Each downward referral will increase by 200 points, reaching 700 points; each received downward referral will increase by 300 points, reaching 500 points.1

Third is the budgetary tool. The "Pilot Program for Individual Hospital Prospective Budgeting and Zonal Co-management" guides hospitals to adjust their ratio of inpatient to outpatient services within a certain total budget cap and uses strategic alliances to refer minor illness or stable chronic patients downward.1

How to Read These Two Curves

If you only look at the proportion of primary care, you will conclude that "tiered medical care is a success." If you only look at the primary care rate of medical centers, you will conclude that "hospitals are still treating minor illnesses."1

A more honest reading is this: the center of gravity in terms of volume is indeed shifting toward primary care—the rise in the share of claims from 61.50% to 64.09% represents a substantive change. However, minor illnesses have not truly disappeared from large hospitals; instead, the primary care rate at medical centers has actually risen slightly.

The report lists both curves simultaneously, noting that the analysis of the primary care rate is "worth noting" and pointing out that the relationship between the rising proportion of primary care and this slight increase in the primary care rate "warrants further investigation."1

The next point of observation will be whether the adjustment of referral points and the co-management pilot in September 2025 can turn the medical center curve from an upward trend to a flat one. Until then, the figures 92.01% and 18.37% will coexist.

Further Reading:

References

  1. 2024 National Health Insurance Supervisory Indicator Monitoring Report (National Health Insurance Administration, Ministry of Health and Welfare, November 2025) — Indicator 1.4 specifies the primary care rates for hospitals at the regional level or above from 2022–2024 (overall: 17.21%, 18.01%, 18.37%; medical centers: 14.40%, 15.13%, 15.56%; regional hospitals: 19.34%, 20.13%, 20.18%; district hospitals: 30.26%, 30.56%, 30.51%) and the definition of primary care; Indicator 1.5 specifies the proportion of outpatient visits and share of claims for Western medicine primary care and hospitals (92.01%, 62.20%; 64.09%, 35.91%); the same report also notes the 81 strategic alliances and 6,844 institutions, the adjustment to 700 points for downward referrals and 500 points for receiving downward referrals on September 1, 2025, and the outpatient volume reduction claim shares of 57.4% and 57.8% for the first and second quarters of 2025.↩234567891011121314151617
About this article This article was collaboratively written with AI assistance and community review.
Tags
Tiered Medical Care Referrals National Health Insurance Primary Care Hospitals Medical Resources
Share

Further Reading

You might also like

Lifestyle Evolving · Awaiting fact-check

Medical Satisfaction: Hospitals Stuck at 94.1%, Dissatisfaction Rises from 1.6% to 3.1%

In 2024, public satisfaction with hospital medical outcomes was 94.1%, identical to 2022 and 2023; Western medicine primary care rose from 94.2% to 96.4%, dentistry 96.3%, Chinese medicine 95.3%. However, hospital dissatisfaction rose from 1.6% to 3.1%, with reasons mainly being physician technique, cursory consultations, and insufficient explanation of conditions. The survey had 2,075 valid hospital samples with a sampling error of approximately ±3 percentage points, and since 2017 it has asked about medical visit experience. This article uses NHIA monitoring indicators to break down satisfaction differences and methodological limitations across four sectors (hospitals, Western medicine primary care, dentistry, Chinese medicine).

閱讀全文
Lifestyle Evolving · Awaiting fact-check

Rural Healthcare: Physician Ratios Between Urban and Rural Areas are 9x Overall, 83x for Hospital Departments

2024 NHIA monitoring indicators show the physician ratio between the most and least urbanized townships is 8.94; for hospital departments, it is 82.95. While hospital and primary care utilization rates are highest in mountainous and outlying island areas, dentistry and Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) rates remain significantly low.

閱讀全文
Lifestyle Evolving · Awaiting fact-check

ER Overcrowding: Among 7.28 Million Visits, 260,000 Waited Over 24 Hours

In 2024, Taiwan's ER visits totaled 7,281,960, with 267,960 cases staying over 24 hours (3.68%, a three-year high); medical centers hit 7.73%, level-1 triage patients 19.30%, while district hospitals fell to 0.69%. Total visits dropped from 2023 but boarding increased; the NHIA attributed causes to presentation, length of stay, and admission, and in 2025 held five meetings, adjusted payment standards, piloted urgent care centers, and raised referral points. This article breaks down the trend using the NHIA monitoring report.

閱讀全文
Economy Evolving · Awaiting fact-check

Care Continuity: The 0.405 Index and the Unexpected Peak During the Pandemic Years

In 2024, the average per-person outpatient care continuity index (COCI) was 0.405, close to the 2019 level of 0.400; during the pandemic years 2020–2022 it rose to 0.436, then fell back after the alert level was lowered. This 0-to-1 index measures whether patients concentrate their visits in a few institutions, calculated using the Bice and Boxerman method, excluding those with three or fewer or 100 or more visits per year. This article uses NHIA monitoring indicators to explain how it is calculated, why the pandemic pushed it up, its relationship with emergency and inpatient utilization, and how policy aims to raise it through the family physician system.

閱讀全文