Nursing Workforce: Three-Shift Nurse-to-Patient Ratios Enacted into Law, and the Medical Center Line That Fell from 42.7% to 8.5%

On May 8, 2026, the Legislative Yuan passed the three-shift nurse-to-patient ratio into the Medical Care Act, using the March 2024 standard as the benchmark, with implementation slated for May 1, 2028. NHI supervisory reports show the share of months where medical centers' all-day nurse-to-patient ratio fell below 7.0 dropped from 42.7% in 2022 to 8.5% in 2024, meaning each nurse cares for more patients. In 2023, the nursing turnover rate was 12.61% and vacancy rate 9.05%, both higher than pre-pandemic 2019; three-shift compliance rose from 50% to 70%. This article breaks down the standards, workforce attrition, and the NT$27.5 billion plan using official indicators.

On May 8, 2026, the Legislative Yuan passed the third reading of amendments to the Medical Care Act, formally writing the three-shift nurse-to-patient ratio into law.1

Minister of Health and Welfare Chiu Tai-yuan (石崇良) explained that evening that nursing groups had hoped for implementation in December 2027, but considering the year-end job-hopping wave and the Lunar New Year holiday, the ministry ultimately recommended May 1, 2028 as the effective date.1

Between legislative passage and formal implementation lies roughly two years. The staffing that must be filled during those two years is the subject of this article.

What the Standard Looks Like

The third-reading text stipulates that the first regulated three-shift nurse-to-patient ratio standard shall be based on the one effective March 1, 2024.1

For medical centers: day shift 1:6, evening shift 1:9, night shift 1:11; for regional hospitals: 1:7, 1:11, 1:13; for district hospitals: 1:10, 1:13, 1:15.1

This standard is stricter than the original "all-day average nurse-to-patient ratio." The original facility standard looked only at the all-day average: medical centers ≤9 patients per nursing staff member, regional hospitals ≤12, district hospitals ≤15.2

The difference lies in "average" versus "by shift." The all-day average can mix low night-shift volume with high day-shift volume; the three-shift system requires every single shift to meet the standard.

Turnover and Vacancy Rates

To understand why a buffer period is needed, one must first look at the workforce attrition numbers.

The Legislative Yuan Budget Center's September 2024 assessment report, citing MOHW data, shows the nationwide hospital nursing staff turnover rate rose from 11.12% in FY 2019 to 12.61% in FY 2023 (112th year), while the vacancy rate climbed from 4.52% to 9.05% — both higher than pre-pandemic levels.3

In 2024, the NHI Administration added the "Strengthening Inpatient Nursing Capacity Program," citing "post-pandemic nursing workforce attrition may lead to insufficient care staff and rising nurse-to-patient ratios," and used night-shift incentives to encourage retention.2

In other words, between 2023 and 2024 the system simultaneously saw "people left" and "the workload on those who stayed got heavier."

That Nurse-to-Patient Ratio Line: 42.7% to 8.5%

The figure in the NHI supervisory report that best illustrates the changing workload is the share of months where medical centers' all-day average nurse-to-patient ratio fell below 7.0.

In 2022 (111th year) it was 42.7%; in 2023 (112th year) it dropped to 10.3%; in 2024 (113th year) only 8.5% remained.2

This decline is not good news. A lower nurse-to-patient ratio means each nurse cares for fewer patients; the share of months below 7.0 falling from four-tenths to less than one-tenth means the ratio in the remaining months shifted above 7.0. The report also notes that the ratio is affected by changes in patient volume and bed count (medical center acute general beds increased by 1,881 compared to end-2023).

The other end of the same chart is also growing. The share of months where medical centers' ratio fell in the 8.0–8.4 range reached 18.2% in 2024; the 8.5–8.9 range accounted for 5.5%.2

Medical center all-day average nurse-to-patient ratio below 7.0 — monthly share (%)
Medical center all-day average nurse-to-patient ratio below 7.0 — monthly share (%)10.38.52023202442.7
Medical center all-day average nurse-to-patient ratio below 7.0 — monthly share (%)
202242.7Four-tenths of months below 7.0
202310.3
20248.5

Source: NHI Supervisory Indicator Monitoring Results Report 2024, Indicator 2.4

For regional hospitals, the <10.0 monthly share fell from 78.8% in 2022 to 58.2% in 2023, then rebounded to 61.9% in 2024 (up 3.7 percentage points from 2023).2

Compliance Bonus Share: District Hospitals Lowest

Another angle is the "bonus-eligible monthly share" — the proportion of months hospitals reported qualifying for the inpatient nursing care add-on payment.

In 2024, medical centers 99.1% (100% in 2022 and 2023; the 2024 dip due to one medical center undergoing renovation), regional hospitals 99.3% (99.2% in 2022, 99.0% in 2023), district hospitals 90.9% (91.8% in 2022, 92.4% in 2023).2

2024 all-day average nurse-to-patient ratio bonus-eligible monthly share (%)
Regional hospitals
99.3 Highest of three tiers
Medical centers
99.1 100% in 2022–2023
District hospitals
90.9 Lowest of three tiers

Source: NHI Supervisory Indicator Monitoring Results Report 2024, Indicator 2.4

District hospitals have been the lowest for three consecutive years. But in 2024, only 0.3% of months were truly "non-compliant"; the remaining ~8.8% were "not applicable" (no inpatient cases admitted that month or not reported).2

Money: NT$33.5 Billion and NT$27.5 Billion

System investment can be divided into two ledgers.

From 2009 to 2024, the NHI side continuously allocated inpatient nursing-related budgets totaling NT$33.5 billion, used to adjust inpatient nursing care payment standards; in 2025 an additional NT$6.5 billion from the general budget was injected to strengthen inpatient care capacity.2

The Executive Yuan then approved the "12-Strategy Nursing Workforce Policy Preparation Plan" in July 2024, spanning 2025–2028, totaling NT$27.5 billion.1

The item most directly tied to retention is incentives. Chiu Tai-yuan explained that starting in 2024, NHI budget has funded night-shift subsidies, and plans roughly NT$2 billion annually in "three-shift nurse-to-patient ratio compliance bonuses," with funds entirely for nursing staff, usable flexibly by hospitals for day-shift, specialist nurses, or holiday allowances.1

Two Senses of Time

In the same meeting, the medical and nursing communities held different views on "when it should take effect."

According to CNA, attending Yang Ming Hospital Superintendent Hsieh Ching-hsiang (謝景祥) said the medical community worries nursing staff cannot be filled in time and hopes for a buffer period; otherwise it would not be a matter of short-term or long-term pain, but continuous pain.1

Nursing Association Federation Chairperson Chen Li-chin (陳麗琴) stated that nursing groups hoped for December 2027 implementation, while the MOHW's proposed May 2028 "differs by several months"; but she emphasized the key is that the buffer period must not be a vacuum — it must have substantive supporting measures.1

The MOHW's observation metric is the compliance rate. Chiu said the nationwide three-shift nurse-to-patient ratio compliance rate has risen from under 50% in the first half of 2025 to 70% in the second half.1

Penalties and Monitoring

Once enacted, consequences for non-improvement are written into law. By tier: district hospitals fined NT$250,000–500,000; hospitals NT$500,000–1,000,000; medical centers NT$1,000,000–2,000,000 (mountain and offshore medical institutions excepted), fines may be imposed per occurrence continuously; three cumulative failures to correct result in suspension of operations for 1 month to 1 year.4

The monitoring mechanism returns to the NHI. Chiu said future monitoring will use NHI global budget to track inpatient service volume; if a hospital shows abnormal volume reduction, its individual global budget base period will be adjusted, and a complaint platform will be established to supervise bonus fund flow.1

Putting these lines together, the significance of writing the three-shift nurse-to-patient ratio into law is not merely adding a standard, but turning "nursing workforce" from a hospital internal management issue into a public indicator with legal provisions, penalties, incentives, and monitoring.

Whether May 1, 2028 can truly launch, and whether the medical center line will rebound afterward, depends on the compliance and turnover rates over the next two years. The NHI's annually published monthly nurse-to-patient ratio shares will be the first place to verify.21

Further Reading:

References

  1. Medical Care Act Third Reading Enacts Three-Shift Nurse-to-Patient Ratio, Targeting May 1, 2028 Implementation (CNA, 2026-05-08) — Records third-reading text based on March 1, 2024 standard (medical center 1:6/1:9/1:11, etc.), MOHW recommending May 1, 2028 implementation, medical and nursing groups' differing views on buffer period, compliance rate rising from under 50% to 70%, 12-strategy plan NT$27.5 billion and ~NT$2 billion annual compliance bonus.↩234567891011
  2. 2024 National Health Insurance Supervisory Indicator Monitoring Results Report (National Health Insurance Administration, MOHW, November 2025) — Indicator 2.4 records 2022–2024 all-day average nurse-to-patient ratio monthly shares (medical center <7.0 at 42.7%, 10.3%, 8.5%; 8.0–8.4 at 18.2%, etc.), bonus-eligible monthly shares (medical centers 100%, 100%, 99.1%; regional 99.2%, 99.0%, 99.3%; district 91.8%, 92.4%, 90.9%), and facility standard Article 12-1 all-day ratio caps, 2009–2024 NT$33.5 billion nursing budget and 2025 NT$6.5 billion general budget.↩23456789
  3. FY 2025 Central Government General Budget Overall Assessment Report (Legislative Yuan Budget Center, September 2024) — Citing MOHW data, records FY 2019–2023 nationwide hospital nursing staff vacancy rate rising from 4.52% to 9.05%, turnover rate from 11.12% to 12.61%.↩
  4. Three-Shift Nurse-to-Patient Ratio Enacted, Violators Fined NT$500K–2M by Tier (Economic Daily News, 2026-05-08) — Reports third-reading penalty design: district hospitals NT$250K–500K, hospitals NT$500K–1M, medical centers NT$1M–2M (mountain/offshore institutions excepted), continuous per-occurrence fines, three cumulative uncorrected violations incur 1-month to 1-year suspension.↩
About this article This article was collaboratively written with AI assistance and community review.
Tags
Nursing workforce Nurse-to-patient ratio Three-shift nurse-to-patient ratio Medical Care Act NHI Hospitals
Share

Further Reading

You might also like

Society Evolving · Awaiting fact-check

Medical Care Act: Forty Years of Institutional Regulation and Market Tug-of-War

The Medical Care Act was promulgated in 1986, the 2017 amendment redefined physician criminal liability, and in May 2026, the three-shift nurse-to-patient ratio became law. The law can dictate "how many beds a nurse can manage at most," but it cannot dictate "whether there is a nurse available." Out of 320,000 nursing licenses, only 190,000 hands remain in clinical practice. This is not the Health Insurance Act or the Medical Practitioners Act; it is the foundational law governing how "hospitals" as institutions exist in Taiwan, and the unresolved tug-of-war between medical public welfare and market mechanisms over the past four decades.

閱讀全文
Lifestyle Evolving · Awaiting fact-check

Taiwan's Healthcare and National Health Insurance: The World's First, Sustained by 99.6% Coverage Atop a 12.61% Nurse Turnover Rate

The NHI card launched on March 1, 1995 was a last-minute rush job: six days prior, the cards hadn't even been printed. Thirty years later, the medical rights of 23 million people rest on a 5.17% premium rate, a 12.61% nurse turnover rate, and a 99.6% coverage rate. This article traces from IC cards, global budgets and point values to the NHI Administration's 2024 supervisory indicators: ER boarding exceeding 24 hours at 3.68%, terminal cancer palliative care at about 60%, acute inpatient stay at 7.3 days, primary care rate at regional hospitals and above at 18.37%, and an annual overall assessment of 10 improvements and 8 regressions, using 23 data points to examine where this system stands today.

閱讀全文
Lifestyle Evolving · Awaiting fact-check

Palliative Care and Patient Autonomy: World Third Place Ranking, and a 0.5% Signing Rate

In 2023, Taiwan's palliative care utilization rate in the year before death was 30.9%, comparable to the U.S. rate of 30.3%; the 2025 Global Palliative Care Map ranked Taiwan third worldwide and first in Asia. Yet as of end-2024, cumulative advance palliative care directives totaled 1.03 million (5.2% of adults), while advance medical decisions numbered only ~94,000 (0.5%), with 87,835 new directives signed in 2024. This article uses the official annual report to break down two laws, 581 service institutions, 279 counseling institutions, 871 palliative beds, and the gap between concentration in the six special municipalities and low rates in outlying islands.

閱讀全文
Lifestyle Evolving · Awaiting fact-check

ER Overcrowding: Among 7.28 Million Visits, 260,000 Waited Over 24 Hours

In 2024, Taiwan's ER visits totaled 7,281,960, with 267,960 cases staying over 24 hours (3.68%, a three-year high); medical centers hit 7.73%, level-1 triage patients 19.30%, while district hospitals fell to 0.69%. Total visits dropped from 2023 but boarding increased; the NHIA attributed causes to presentation, length of stay, and admission, and in 2025 held five meetings, adjusted payment standards, piloted urgent care centers, and raised referral points. This article breaks down the trend using the NHIA monitoring report.

閱讀全文